The quality of the olive oil produced this year is much lower than the average of the past years. Our R&D laboratory made its annual analytical study of some samples of olive oil produced in Tuscany and the results obtained confirms a low quality influenced by more than one factor.

The problems of 2014 olive harvest

Actually the problems of the olive harvest started since springtime when a scarce flowering and the difficulties in the fruit set represented an alarm in some districts. In July and August the rain conditioned the olive grove, creating the perfect environment for the develop of the olive fly that did big defects in the fruits.

The high levels of the FFA values were surprising since the beginning of the analyses, with values that arrive beyond 0,8%, the maximum limit to classify the olive oil as “extra virgin”.

The analysis of polyphenols confirmed as well all the problems of a difficult harvest, presenting values distinctly below the averages of past years.

What you will find in this article

We correlated the polyphenols’ values with the summer rainfalls with to understand better the causes of a so low quality olive oil production in an area where generally the oil produced has a good quality.

In the article you will find the results of the study and the figures of the analyses performed with CDR OxiTester, together with a short comment, a comparison with other olive harvest data and an overview of the situation in the oil mills during this year, that turns out a very particular year. Finally some suggestions to check the quality and to avoid bad surprises.

The study led by the CDR chemical laboratory.

Oil quality and summer rainfalls

The quality of the oil till now produced is remarkably low. The most surprisingly datum emerging from the analyses of our samples is about the value of the polyphenols that are scarce also where the values of FFA and peroxide value are good. What could it be the reason of so low values?

All the defects coming from the olive fly affected highly the FFA value but it could be not possible a so strong effect on polyphenols. Given that our annual statistics are made on samples coming always from the same area of origin, where the same cultivar are cultivated, generally milled in the same oil mills, we thought the data of the polyphenols could have been to the summer rainfalls in some way. In the last year we saw a great increase of rainfall in the months of July and August. To verify our hypothesis we considered the previous four years in which we analysed the oils coming from a definite area of Tuscany. We considered millimetres of rainfalls in this area, taking the average of data surveyed by three hydrological stations. We correlated then the two series of data.

Fig. 1: Area of origin of the samples

Tabella 1: Data divided per year

Fig. 2: Data Correlation Graphic




In addition to rainfalls, many other data can influence the content of polyphenols in oil: ripeness level of the olives, cultivar, times and methods of extraction. Nevertheless data prove a neat correlation with the summer rainfalls as well. However the rains favour the develop of the olive fly and can be recognized as the main cause of all the criticalities of the olive harvest 2014.

Obviously our hypothesis requests further checks and studies extended in time and in space. However it contributes to indicate the trend of an interesting quality parameter, polyphenols, in relation to the climate changing in progress, and to think about the most appropriate interventions to operate in the field or in the mill.

Analyses of the samples

The parameters for quality control (FFA, peroxide value and polyphenols) have been checked on samples of oils coming from the Florence and Pistoia districts, received by the Cerbaia cooperative OTA oil mill.


Table 2: Analysis carried out with OxiTester

The values of the three analyses performed on the samples, to which has been given a quality index (high – medium – low) mainly based on the value of polyphenols, are reported in the table from the highest to the lowest FFA value. Right the FFA values are the most alarming, because they are in average higher than the values generally found in oils freshly pressed. As shown in the table, the half of the samples are not “extra virgin” but classified as “virgin” or “lampante virgin olive oil”.

Results of 2014 analyses in comparison with those of the past years

We pointed out some differences between this year olive oil quality and past years’ olive oil quality as they appear in the analytical studies of our laboratory:

  • A general lowering of the oil quality
  • The average value of the polyphenols is low: only two of the 47 samples present a value over 150 mg/Kg, that is the limit over which we define the high quality samples. In the previous years the polyphenols in average have always been over 140 mg/Kg
  • The most part of the “extra virgin” samples are placed in the quality range Medium and Low, while in other years Very High quality samples were present
  • Since we are realizing our studies about the olive oil quality control of the year in Tuscany, we never found that almost the half of the samples analysed were into the categories of “virgin” and “lampante virgin” oil (in red and yellow colour in the table)
  • Peroxide values, even if they are in average higher than the quality standard of the freshly pressed oils (values ranging from a minimum of 3,09 meqO2/Kg and a maximum of 20,37 meqO2/Kg), are acceptable and in line with expectations

In conclusion, in comparison with the past seasons, extra virgin oils with a low content of polyphenols, are not going to have the typical scents and aromas of the high quality fresh new olive oil. Moreover it is possible that the oils, scarce from a quality point of view, will have some problems in its preservation.

The situation in oil mills in Tuscany

The activity period of the mills was short and anticipated. In fact, many small olive growers have decided not to harvest olives because they are scarce or too compromised, or even fallen prematurely due to the enormous defects.

Others, after an initial harvest, decided to stop work due to the low quality of the produced oil. Only those who have done adequate and repeated treatments with insecticides have been able to "save" the harvest and their oil.

Some olive mills run out of last year's oil stocks already in September, because of the exceptional demand from consumers and small producers. In fact, this oil, if of high quality and stored well, has certainly maintained the good characteristics it had at the beginning. Something that will most likely not happen with the majority of oils produced this year.

Monitor quality to avoid surprises

The analysis of the oil has been particularly appreciated during this olive oil campaign and has represented a crucial factor in managing the "oil quality" emergency within the mills and will be even more important as an element of control to prevent or contrast counterfeiting or fraud, which could find opportunities in such risky years.

The chemical analysis of the oil has always been a valid tool to monitor the quality and avoid surprises during the production, storage and classification phases. In fact, quality controls are very useful for the classification of oils and even more during critical and uncertain years.

For some time now, the analysis of acidity, peroxides and polyphenols has been carried out in the mills in a simple and direct way immediately after the olive pressing process, using a single drop of oil, thanks to CDR OxiTester. On the production line as well as in the storage warehouses, it is possible to carry out an accurate quality control that is enhanced and intensified during an abnormal year such as 2014. Due to climate change and market demands, the control at the root of the production chain will become increasingly important.